Diễn Đàn Đất Đai

Criteria

Judging Criteria and Attributes

This section provides the guidelines for judges – the criteria and weightings and the criteria’s attributes and weightings – to be used in judging process in the APICTA Award competition.

 

A. Head Categories

Head Category: Consumer (HC-C)

Judging Criteria Weighting Attributes Weighting
Uniqueness 25% Technology and Innovation 60%
Trend Setting, creativity 40%
Market Potential 25% Market Share & Potential 60%
Business and Financial Model/Strategy 40%
Functionalities and Features 25% User Requirements 50%
Compatibility and Interoperability 50%
Quality & Application of Technology 25% Content & Standard 60%
Product Stability & Reliability 40%

 

Head Category: Inclusions and Community (HC-IC)

Judging Criteria Weighting Attributes Weighting
Uniqueness 25% Technology and Innovation 40%
Trend Setting 60%
Value to Community & Society at large 30% Accessibility & Reach 50%
Social Integration & Impact on Quality of Life 50%
Functionalities and Features 25% User Requirement 50%
Compatibility and Interoperability 50%
Quality & Application of Technology 20% Content & Standards 60%
Product Stability & Reliability 40%

 

Head Category: Industrial (HC-I)

Judging Criteria Weighting Attributes Weighting
Uniqueness 30% Technology and Innovation 60%
Trend Setting, creativity 40%
Market Potential 20% Market Share & Potential 60%
Business and Financial Model/Strategy 40%
Functionalities and Features 30% User Requirement 50%
Compatibility and Interoperability 50%
Quality & Application of Technology 20% Content & Standard 60%
Product Stability & Reliability 40%

 

Head Category: Business Services (HC-BS)

Judging Criteria Weighting Attributes Weighting
Uniqueness 25% Technology and Innovation 60%
Trend Setting, creativity 40%
Market Potential 20% Market Share & Potential 60%
Business and Financial Model/Strategy 40%
Functionalities and Features 25% User Requirements 50%
Compatibility and Interoperability 50%
Quality & Application of Technology 30% Content & Standard 60%
Product Stability & Reliability 40%

 

Head Category: Public Sector and Government (HC-PSG)

Judging Criteria Weighting Attributes Weighting
Uniqueness 25% Technology and Innovation 60%
Trend Setting, creativity 40%
Value to Public/ Government 30% Accessibility & Reach 50%
Transparency & Impact on Quality of Life 50%
Functionalities and Features 25% User Requirement 50%
Compatibility and Interoperability 50%
Quality & Application of Technology 20% Content & Standards 60%
Product Stability & Reliability 40%

 

Head Category: STUDENTS’ Project (HC-S):

Junior Students, Senior Students, Tertiary Students (Undergraduate)

Judging Criteria Weighting Attributes Weighting
Uniqueness 15% Application of Technologies 50%
Innovation 50%
Proof of Concept 15% Understanding of the Problem to be Solved 50%
Understanding of Business Environment 50%
Functionalities and Features 15% User Requirement 50%
Compatibility and Interoperability 50%
Quality 30% Content & Standards 60%
Product Stability & Reliability 40%
Presentation 25% Organization of Presentation 50%
Enquiries 50%

 

B. Cross Categories

Start-Up of the Year (CC-SU)

Judging Criteria Weighting Attributes Weighting
Business Model & Financials 30% Funding 50%
Scalability of operations 50%
Client Reach 15% Quality / type of clients 50%
Satisfaction 50%
Execution –

Team Composition – Implementation

 

20%

Scalability of Operation 50%
Team Composition 50%
Investment Viability 10% Quality of Customer Base 50%
Market Share / Potential 50%
Unique Selling Proposition 25% Market Entry Barrier/IPR 50%
Competitive Advantage & Differentiation 50%

 

Research and Development Project of the Year (CC-RD)

Judging Criteria Weighting Attributes Weighting
Uniqueness 30% Technology and Innovation 60%
Trend Setting, creativity 40%
Proof of Concept 30% Commercial Potential 50%
Pilot Trial 50%
Functionalities and Features 20% User Requirement 50%
Compatibility and Interoperability 50%
Quality & Application of Technology 20% Content & Standards 60%
Product Stability & Reliability 40%

 

C. Technology Categories

Big Data Analytics (CT-BDA)

Judging Criteria Weighting Attributes Weighting
Security 30% Solution architecture and/or platform design 60%
Compliance / adherence to security standards 40%
Creativity 30% Process of Data Mining, Algorithm Used and Results Management 50%
Elements of Predictive & Prescriptive Analytics 50%
Scale 20% Proof of how solution will scale and adopt to business needs 50%
Seamless Data & Process Integration 50%
Openness Integrability 20% Demonstrate compliance to industry standards 60%
Integration of third party solutions to enhance and/or monitor 40%

 

Internet of Things (CT-IOT)

Judging Criteria Weighting Attributes Weighting
Security 30% Solution architecture and/or platform design 60%
Compliance / adherence to security standards 40%
Creativity 30% Purpose & Ease of Use 50%
Area of deployment for efficiencies and advantage points 50%
Scale 20% Proof of how solution will scale 50%
Ease of deployment and productivity & Integration for business use 50%
Openness Integrability 20% Demonstrate compliance to industry standards 60%
Integration of third party solutions to enhance and/or monitor 40%

 

Artificial Intelligence (CT-AI)

Judging Criteria Weighting Attributes Weighting
Security 30% Solution architecture and/or platform design 60%
Compliance / adherence to security standards 40%
Creativity 30% Solving or enhancing processes, capabilities and efficiencies 50%
Methodologies used in producing results, self learning 50%
Scale 20% Proof of how solution will scale 50%
Ease of deployment and 50%
Openness Integration 20% Demonstrate compliance to industry standards 60%
Integration of third party solutions to enhance and/or monitor 40%

 

Block Chain (CT-BC)

Judging Criteria Weighting Attributes Weighting
Value to society 30% Saving the cost 50%
Enhance security or transparency 50%
Market Potential 30% Market share & Potential 50%
Business and Financial Model/Strategy 50%
Functionalities & Features 20% User requirement 50%
Compatibility and Interoperability 50%
Openness Integration 20% Demo compliance to industry standards 50%
Integration of third party solutions to enhance and/or monitor 50%